QUOTE(nothingbroken @ Mar 15 2008, 06:14 PM) [snapback]174714[/snapback]
Best show I've ever seen was HBO's Carnivale. It was practically perfect in every way. Brilliant, engaging, complex, and occasionally frightening storyline. Deep and fascinating characters played by highly talented actors and actresses. Innovative ideas, cool setting, great music... the whole works.
It mostly stretched out too long.
I couldn't really point to much that was going to waste but every episode was more than fifty minutes long and the show ambled with very little direction.
The last six episodes did pretty much kick all kinds of ass, though.
I will say that my experience may have been somewhat ruined by watching it with my cousin. He and I tend to argue and then wax poetic about the characters in any experience. It's not rare for a poignant, touching or tense moment to be ruined by some impromptu dialogue from the peanut gallery.
QUOTE(dreamchaser @ Mar 16 2008, 12:47 AM) [snapback]174727[/snapback]
Let us not forget Rome. Same thing. Where's my promised 3rd season? What a great show! Time for a DVD re-watch, I think.
I'm pretty sure cost was a big factor in Rome.
Cost and a lack of cohesion.
See, the first season was perfectly timed. Caesar's grab for power went really well. The second season had a bit more trouble, Augustus' seizing of power and his later consolidation.
But splitting up the next few of the Julio-Claudian emperors would have been incredibly difficult. Not to mention that nearly all interpretations of Nero and Caligula are hotly contested in the small and nerdish circles they are considered in. Would sure have been sweet to see my favourite two rulers played out at that level of excellence, though.