Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: is it just me
Looking for Group » Forums > LFG Main Forums > The Comic
Pages: 1, 2
minamato
in the latest comic, the one where gid is glaring at the pirate captain, the one with the flaming cats, (page 47) did anyone else think that the glare said some thing more like "hey sexy, my cabins over there." than "i'll slit your throat in your sleep"? plus, the cats loved each other. an analogy for gid and the captain? wink.gif
GID HAS A GIRLFRIEND!!!!!!! wub.gif tongue.gif tongue.gif

so, evil glare or come-on, i'll let you decide.
the_one
I thought I was the only one who thought that!
minamato
QUOTE (the_one @ May 28 2007, 10:19 PM) *
I thought I was the only one who thought that!


defiantly not. gid is smiling at her!!!

plus, whats with gid's suddenly see through skirt?
Lunaya
blink.gif I thought it was just a "I'm only pretending to be civil until I get the chance to kill you" kind of grin. Plus, Benny probably only went for a sheer skirt because it's hot out. More air can get through.
minamato
QUOTE (Lunaya @ May 28 2007, 10:46 PM) *
blink.gif I thought it was just a "I'm only pretending to be civil until I get the chance to kill you" kind of grin. Plus, Benny probably only went for a sheer skirt because it's hot out. More air can get through.



yeah im sure. wink.gif
Admiral_Kelly
Based on the way Richard and Cale described the situation, I think the look was non-lesbian; more like a girl-rivalry hate-your-guts kindof smile. The cats falling in love thing was most likely put in for comedic effect and not symbolism.

And seriously, do you think the authors would start a gratuitous love relationship (be it homo or hetro) when you have a good plot running along? It would totally ruin the story.
minamato
they might....LFG need some love, so far its just blood and gore and laughing at it.
The Lone David
It could use a little love, and the ghost of Bob Marley, everything is better with Bob Marley.
minamato
QUOTE (The Lone David @ May 28 2007, 11:03 PM) *
It could use a little love, and the ghost of Bob Marley, everything is better with Bob Marley.



too true david, to true.
Kinda_Mayvelle
Yes, I also thought it was one of those female rivalry "I'll pretend to be nice and sweet and civil until I get you alone in a dark nook on the ship in the middle of the night where I can stab you clean through the chest" kind of thing. You see it in high schools all the time these days. The kittens falling in love was just adorable (and rather funny). If you happen to see one attempting to throttle the life out of the other, don't be surprised. Ya shoulda seen it comin'.
Lunaya
Yeah, I think the kittens playing nice was just a way to give Richard an excuse to torch something. Don't you love the irritated look on his face when the cats don't fight?
GutterBall
Actually, it looks to me like Benny's smiling a bit flirtatiously...but Cap'n One-eye isn't. And I think Richard just can't imagine two women getting along; thus, the cat analogy that kinda petered out on him. Might have worked with older cats, but kitties just tend to cuddle and purr.

Of course, we could all be waaaay off base, and it could be something totally different. Can't wait to find out, personally.
The Lone David
Perhaps they're planning to hijack them all to be given as gifts to a tribe of Amazons.
GutterBall
Heh, women scorned and all that. I can see it.
The Lone David
Crazy woman-warrior antics, sounds hot...
lunytoon deal with it
HAHA theres nothing wrong with tall women to just make a point i'm 12 and i'm 6 foot
Grym
i dont know... you cant really see bennies eyes, she could just be having a good dream and the captain is pissed at her for being lazy
GutterBall
There ya go. Perfectly plausible explanation.
The Lone David
Except Benny's got that evil grin on her face, the kind that says: "I'm going to cut out your eyes."
Demonor
who to trust, Cale or the cats... im going with the cats...
Vorin
Nothing I've seen leads me to make an opinion on the sexual orintations of any of the characters in this comic. Then again, I might have missed something.

The only character Benny has shown a (non-familial) attraction to is Richard. And that may be that she's merely amused by him rather than attracted to him. (I personally think otherwise, but I shouldn't let my opinions cloud the facts, especially with so little information to go on!)
paradoxfive
To me Benny has a smug smile on her face, the kind of like the cat that eat the canary type look. most likey due to the captains crew has been 'checking her out more' then their captain, which explains the 'annoyed' look of the captain.
Grym
QUOTE (The Lone David @ May 29 2007, 09:51 PM) *
Except Benny's got that evil grin on her face, the kind that says: "I'm going to cut out your eyes."

maybe shes having a good evil dream... a dream about eye cutting?
Melfina-chan
Alright, you've finally convinced me to sign up for this bloody forum. I've resisted the urge to make comments for so long now...and here's my first.
Benny is NOT smiling.
Not grinning.
Not happy.
That 'line' pointing up is her tusk. That one pointing down is her lip-line. To me, it looks like she's scoffing, and about ready to throw something at the captain. Maybe lunge for her throat. Oh, and her eyes are there, just squinted into small, spiteful slits. (Alliteration ftw)

And about her skirt--whoo! Go Benny. I like it. Looks like something good for dancing in. (Yes, I'm one of those who think she is a troll, and since the ones I'm most associated with (that look like her...you know, the WoW ones >.>) tend to dance all the time...*nodnod* Yeah. Plus, they belly dance, so it's just that much better of an outfit for it! It even looks like she has the cute little belly they tend to get.)


((I ask that you forgive my irritated tone...I just noticed that absolutely nobody seemed to be able to tell that she was a very unhappy Benny. And I have a small screen. >_>' I really do love and adore this comic, it's excellent, the videos are fun, can't wait for the next update. <3 LFG FTW))
Grym
uh.... benny doesnt have tusks... she has one overgrown tooth, but she is smiling in that panel... and you cant see her eyes, one is covered by her haired, and the other is shaded by her hair enough to make it not visible enough for distinguishable emotion.
Melfina-chan
Mmkay, so it's just one tusk. You're right, I don't remember seeing more than one at a time. Except for that time on page 9 (not sure of any others that might be floating around), but that could just be emphasizing her irritation. Anyway.

If you look at just about any page with her mouth closed, you can see her one tusk sticking out. If you look at the page in question, her tooth is sticking out...and her mouth curves down at the end. I wouldn't define that as a smile, myself.

Yes, one eye is covered. I can see the other one...at least, I can see a tiny, lightly-colored slit that I would assume is an eye, and not a poor coloring job. Squinting at it, I can see what looks like the spot of her iris/pupil in the right corner, looking at our dear captain. (Was also using the built-in magnifier thing on my mouse.)

Plus, we can't ignore the fact that Cale said: "They've been glaring at each other for the past ten days."

Smiling =/= glaring
Grym
yes but it could be a im going to kill you and dine on your heart smile. it looks like a frown because you're sort of seeing her profile, so the curving up part is very small

i dont think the eye is really clear enough to show emotion.

as for cale, he LIES. hes an elf, theyre evil. ergo hes evil. we all know hes just a spy sent to get the angry sword to kill every non-elf.
The Lone David
Just a quick point, it's not a tusk or a tooth, its the wrinkle of her cheek caused by her evil grin.
Melfina-chan
*points to the left side of her mouth* It points down. The pointy-uppy part is a tooth. The other side...*points to the right* Is a foreshortening of the other half of her mouth, and does not indicate direction of her expression in any shape or form. You don't see all of her mouth--the part that would be the pointy-downy part of it is hidden behind the pointy-uppy part, since it curves around her face. See how the far side (on the left) of the captain's mouth points up, too? (Sorry if that ended up excessively confusing. ^.^')

Nah, it's not really clear enough for that...partially because it is just slitted...but it's still not a positive expression. One way or the other, she's not happy with the captain. At least we can agree on that part.

...lol, nice. That might be funny to see...but he's too naive to be a spy. Or, he's a really, really good actor, and has been practicing from page one. But I don't think he's that deep.

(edit)
David: Not likely. She doesn't seem to be pudgy enough for it to be. It would curve the other way (like < not >) if it were a grin.
The Lone David
You don't have to be pudgy for it to be like that, you just have to be a cartoon.
Grym
QUOTE (The Lone David @ May 30 2007, 08:19 PM) *
Just a quick point, it's not a tusk or a tooth, its the wrinkle of her cheek caused by her evil grin.

it looks like that in that panel, but in other strips you can see it

the captains mouth points up to cause she wants to dine on bennies heart. theyre both smiling

as had been said before, theyre smiling in an "i hate you i want to slit your throat(i might have paraphrased a bit)" look. not like theyre glaring and then smiling happy, theyre glaring and smiling i kill you
Melfina-chan
*whips out photoshop* Mmkay. This is how I see it, from my experience with drawing, and reading LFG.

http://i15.photobucket.com/albums/a355/Mel...s-frown-web.png

First being what David is talking about, second is how I would have drawn what he was talking about, and third is what I'm talking about. Unfortunately, I can't quite see yours well enough to map it out, grym.

((Note: It'd look better if I wasn't being lazy, and cared to take time on this...or maybe draw it by hand, instead of with my accursed mouse.))

(edit)
Then I got bored and made another one.

http://i15.photobucket.com/albums/a355/Mel...le-examples.png

I think it's self-explanatory...two mouths, what it'd look like from the front and 3/4 views...note that the tiny line on the second one would look pretty much exactly the same if the mouth was not smiling.
The Lone David
Now that I've seen the larger picture I agree with you.
Crioni
Thankyou Melfina, I think that clears it up. *salute*
Melfina-chan
QUOTE (Crioni @ May 31 2007, 07:28 AM) *
Thankyou Melfina, I think that clears it up. *salute*

No problem. I'm happy to help.
/salute
GutterBall
Darn. That does clear it up. And it was such fun to speculate!
Demonor
well todays comic proves it, they hate eachother... darn it,
thoe maby the hate is only on the outside and deep down their hopelessly in love
(hay I can dream cant I?)
iloverichard
if benny was lez then i would die. that would totally ruin the comic forever.

no, i mean... ever.
Melfina-chan
QUOTE (iloverichard @ May 31 2007, 08:59 PM) *
if benny was lez then i would die. that would totally ruin the comic forever.

no, i mean... ever.

...You make me want to scribble in a stick figure female with the picture of Benny I sketched earlier. *shifty-eyed* Just for kicks and giggles. ^o^

And to find out--just how would it ruin everything...? o.O
Admiral_Kelly
Gratuitous love relationships especially those built on lust tend to ruin the story. If Benny were to be all hot over Tah'Vraay it would be for one of the following reasons:

-Fanservice. Generally, although stereotypical, nothing is more pleasing to the male mind than girl-on-girl action. This would be bad as it not only takes away from the plot but also the characters.

-Gay activism. Regardless of what anyone thinks on this issue, do we really want LFG's opinions on the matter or any other social issues? That would completely change the focus on the comic. For the worse in my opinion.

-Gratuitous Romance. I never really went for romance and quite frankly I don't care if "character x likes y and z is jealous while w wants to get into somebody's pants". Stick with the plot line, leave that stuff out (and could you imagine all the fan-created "shipping"? Disturbing.)

If the love relationship was not gratuitous and fit in with the plot, then that would be "OK", but I'd rather not see it in LFG.
GutterBall
QUOTE (Admiral_Kelly @ Jun 1 2007, 07:05 AM) *
(and could you imagine all the fan-created "shipping"? Disturbing.)


Oh, that'll happen anyway. *sigh* One of the curses of creating something people like is knowing that other people are doing horribly sexual things to your beloved adventure characters. Ugh.
iloverichard
well, i think we all know that that would never happen.

slap me if i'm wrong, but i don't think Sohmer would want to mess it up that way, anyway.

seriously.
minamato
i dont think they sohmer they meant fanart tongue.gif and damn. it did kinda get cleared up by the enlarged version of the frame. poo.
Melfina-chan
QUOTE (minamato @ Jun 3 2007, 12:48 PM) *
i dont think they sohmer they meant fanart tongue.gif and damn. it did kinda get cleared up by the enlarged version of the frame. poo.

Hehe, sorry I spoiled your fun, there. Pretend you never saw it? ^_~
iloverichard
i would rather see Richard with Vraay than Benny, hands down. and i'm not saying he wouldn't do well with Benny, either. tongue.gif
Melfina-chan
QUOTE (iloverichard @ Jun 9 2007, 02:59 AM) *
i would rather see Richard with Vraay than Benny, hands down. and i'm not saying he wouldn't do well with Benny, either. tongue.gif

Hasn't this conversation already been done? Richard isn't the type to need, or ever fall for, anyone of any gender. He's just--above the need, I suppose you could say. Give him an orphanage (or other similarly helpless group of people) and he'll be perfectly happy. Until they're gone, of course. Then, he'll just move on to his next victims...

And don't try telling me it can't be true because "people like that don't exist." I have a friend (who happens to be awesome, and a tad bit evil--he loves to creep out the rest of our little group >3 ) who just...I don't know, it's odd. He seems to be asexual, or soemthing very close to it. o.o But definitely full of personality, similar to Richard. Has an excellent evil laugh, too.

((That last part was definitely not me bragging about one of my awesome friends, no...*shifty-eyed*))
Memnarch
how exactly did that clear everything up? What did everyone decide on?
S_CG_Phoenix
I could totally see a Cale and Tavor-shipping fanbase, hell i'm halfway there! laugh.gif
Lunaya
*Screams* Noo! Anything but that! The only thing worse will be if people start pairing Cale and Richard. blink.gif Blech! I can't believe I just typed that. wacko.gif
S_CG_Phoenix
QUOTE (Lunaya @ Jun 10 2007, 01:59 PM) *
*Screams* Noo! Anything but that! The only thing worse will be if people start pairing Cale and Richard. blink.gif Blech! I can't believe I just typed that. wacko.gif

>_<

I dont think Richard and Cale would work, it doesnt work in my head. Cale and Tavor work in my head, so I can see it.

I honestly dont think Richard could work with anyone unless it was another undead person...we need an undead female for Richard. I vote we make ILoveRichard into a character!

/Runs and hides
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.